Recycling to Stop Landslides: 2nd Sustainable Favela Network Exchange Visits Morro dos Prazeres

Clique aqui para Português

The Sustainable Favela Network (SFN) is a project of Catalytic Communities (CatComm)* designed to build solidarity networks, bring visibility, and develop joint actions to support the expansion of community-based initiatives that strengthen environmental sustainability and social resilience in favelas across the Rio de Janeiro Metropolitan Region. The project began with the 2012 film Favela as a Sustainable Model, followed in 2017 by the mapping of 111 sustainability initiatives and the publication of a final report analyzing the results.

In 2018, the project organized on-site exchanges among eight of the oldest and most established organizations that were mapped in the Sustainable Favela Network (one of which is the subject of this article), followed by a full-day exchange with the entire network that took place on November 10. The eight participants in the on-site exchanges featured in this series include six community-based organizations: the Vale Encantado Cooperative in Alto da Boa VistaEccoVida in Honório GurgelVerdejar in Engenho da Rainha and Complexo do AlemãoQuilombo do Camorim in JacarepaguáReciclAção in Morro dos Prazeres, and Alfazendo’s Eco Network in City of God. In addition, the exchanges visited two broader initiatives focusing beyond favelas with extensive experience in sustainability: Onda Verde in Nova Iguaçu and the Sepetiba Ecomuseum. The program is supported by the Heinrich Böll Foundation Brazil.

Watch the video that accompanies the exchanges featured in this series by clicking here.

The Afternoon of the Second Exchange: ReciclAção, Morro dos Prazeres

ReciclAção at work on a typical weekday in PrazeresOn September 8, the afternoon of the second Sustainable Favela Network (SFN) exchange took place in Morro dos Prazeres—a community located at the top of Santa Teresa in Central Rio. While geographically and demographically distinct from Vale Encantado, which hosted the morning visit, both communities have unique relationships to the natural environment entangled with histories of eviction threats and creative resistance. Both Vale Encantado and Prazeres are home to community activists who work to combat the stigmatization of favelas as unsustainable, showing that many favela residents are agents of environmental protection and awareness and that favelas can indeed serve as models of sustainability.

Upon arriving in Prazeres, the SFN group visited an eco-point managed by community-based organization ReciclAção (“RecyclAction”). The eco-points, distributed throughout the community, collect between 1-1.5 tons of recyclable material per month and are an integral aspect of ReciclAção’s work to protect the natural environment in Prazeres. In addition to collecting recyclable materials, ReciclAção facilitates environmental education in schools and nature walks in the community. In its five years of existence, the organization has collected 84 tons of recyclable materials (via eco-points alone) and hosted 180 community breakfasts, 45 community clean-ups, and 250 workshops on the reuse of waste materials. ReciclAção’s work has also expanded to collecting over 2,600 liters of used cooking oil to prevent it from solidifying and entering the sewage system.

Building Resilience from Tragedy

ReciclAção’s creation was inspired by a tragedy: in 2010, heavy rains affecting favelas across Rio caused a landslide on a slope that had been covered in trash for decades in Prazeres. Over thirty people were killed and 355 families were left homeless. The disaster forced residents to reevaluate their relationship with waste management. In the words of ReciclAção founder and community organizer Cris dos Prazeres: “It was a tragic moment. And [it made me] think and rethink, as a local activist…about how to connect our network… It was a moment in which we saw that human beings manage to show solidarity, especially in times of pain.”

The view from Prazeres, overlooking Santa Teresa and downtown Rio

ReciclAção grew out of an existing community-based organization, Prevenção Realizada com Organização e Amor—PROA (Prevention Realized Through Organization and Love), which has worked to address public health issues in the community since 1998. While PROA already hosted community clean-ups and worked to spread information about mosquito-borne diseases, the organization had not worked extensively on environmental issues until after the 2010 landslide with the development of a community mapping project in partnership with the Center for the Promotion of Health (CEDAPS), a local NGO that works in the city’s favelas; the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF); and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Led by a group of local youth, the mapping exercise confirmed the need for environmental education and training surrounding natural disaster response and prevention strategies in Prazeres.

Homes in a square along the pedestrian graffiti path in Prazeres

ReciclAção was formed in response to this need in 2013 as a project that not only works to protect the environment but also dialogues between health, education, social assistance, and environmental issues in Prazeres. Describing the organization’s early development, Cris explained that her team began asking companies for donations “after the mapping, after problematizing everything—after taking a breath.” One company agreed to a pilot project, which they called ReciclAção. Cris described ReciclAção’s current work as encompassing “a giant platform: education and health to promote the environment.”

The Strength of Local Networks in Resisting Eviction Threats

The natural disaster was not the only threat that residents of Prazeres faced in 2010. As Cris recalled, “At six in the morning the next day [after the landslide], our mayor said, ‘We are removing Morro dos Prazeres.’” Realizing that they needed tools and professional support to mobilize their network and advocate against the eviction threat, Cris explained: “In one week, the whole favela came together like never before because we [already] had our network. We had a group of local volunteers—we always must involve residents… At that moment, we saw that all of PROA’s work made a lot of sense. We already had community engagement; we [already] had solidarity among residents.”

Cris presents the work of ReciclAção do the Sustainable Favela Network group

To fight against the eviction threat, community activists connected with institutions that provide legal support to guarantee communities’ right to remain on their land, including the State Public Defender’s Office’s House and Lands Nucleus (NUTH) and the Catholic Church’s Pastoral das Favelas. As Cris recounted, the entire community came together: “When we truly need to come together, we unite.”

According to public defender Maria Lúcia de Pontes, who attended the SFN exchange, the language used by Rio’s government in the eviction effort was a “discourse of pain and fear.” Pontes explained that government officials cited the deaths of favela residents resulting from the disaster as a motive for eviction. Pontes called the government’s logic “cruel,” as residents who did not agree to resettlement were blamed for their neighbors’ deaths.

Sustainable Favela Network members listen and ask questions

Pontes explained to the group that the combination of residents’ mobilization efforts and their collaboration with academic researchers and outside professionals worked to disprove the government’s claim that eviction was the only means of guarding against environmental risk. “Most fundamental of all was that mobilization,” said Pontes. “We held large assemblies, we carried out many projects and internal discussions, and in the end, we didn’t [need to] initiate any legal process [to defend the community].” Residents’ activism, bolstered by Prazeres’ large network of supporters, successfully worked to combat the government’s narrative surrounding evictions in Prazeres: “It was all of that work that created the resistance,” said Pontes.

Defying Expectations with Local Technologies

On retelling the early stages of ReciclAção’s development, Cris described how many people did not believe that the group would succeed: “They said, ‘You all are crazy. This is not going to work. Favela residents, stopping to look at trash? Separating trash? Doing trash collection? You all are dreaming.’” However, Cris explained, those who do not live in favelas and are unfamiliar with the reality of favelas do not understand what residents are capable of achieving. While “the favela is synonymous with a lack of control, a lack of rules” in the popular imagination, Cris explained, “when we look at the favela, we find a place that is truly one of resilience.”

When asked about her academic qualifications, Cris tells people that she has a doctoral degree in street knowledge: “My knowledge, you’re never going to learn in a university. Never… We are all imprisoned by society’s model [of knowledge]. We need to detach ourselves, value our own knowledge, and seek out the knowledge of others.” Over the past five years, ReciclAção has developed local social technologies, beginning with participatory meetings such as breakfasts and opening up space for community members to discuss environmental issues. For Cris, education is “the key that creates a model of consciousness.” As such, volunteers visit schools to talk to students and churches to speak with religious leaders.

Community garden in Morro dos Prazeres

Without personally knowing everyone in Prazeres, Cris wants everyone to know and feel like they are a part of ReciclAção’s work. When residents take ownership of a project, they become less concerned with what they can get out of it and more concerned with community improvement. Cris especially sees this transformation process during mutirõescollective action projects such as community clean-ups. Describing one clean-up event—in which one hundred residents collected forty tons of trash in just one day—Cris said: “We started to realize that the mutirão is one project that really provides a different perspective. Doing a clean-up in which [participants] don’t make money is incredible… Our motto has always been, ‘[You won’t make money from this, but] you’re going to gain a great community.’”

ReciclAção’s “local technologies” have gained recognition outside of Prazeres: in 2014, the team worked with a network in the United States to develop a manual based on their methodology, and in 2015, the organization was certified by the Banco do Brasil Foundation and included in the institution’s Social Technology Bank (BTS).

ReciclAção ecobags filled with sorted recyclables

Throughout the creation and development of ReciclAção, Cris has emphasized the importance of fostering a community-based network that is capable of mobilizing outside support when necessary. Cris believes that the Sustainable Favela Network plays a crucial role in this system. In her words, “networks have force.” ReciclAção is currently in a moment of transition as it restructures into an NGO: Cris described it as a time to “look at ourselves, to reorganize, to work to structure ourselves better, to professionalize.” Describing how the SFN can best support ReciclAção’s work, Cris said: “The best support that the group can provide is sharing information. I think that I am seeing ideas—new ideas… I have already learned a lot from these two visits. They were visits that really already taught me a lot… It is an enriching experience.” Describing the variety of projects and locations of the communities within the SFN, Cris explained that the important part is learning about the processes and methodologies that bring these projects together: “It is an exchange of experiences, of perceptions, of realities… And the network is fundamental for this exchange.”

Following an afternoon spent learning about RecilAção’s work to unite the community of Prazeres in the name of sustainability, Sustainable Favela Network members closed the day in reflection. Linking arms in a tightly-knit circle, each participant shared a word that captures what they will take away from the exchange: “Experience. Gathering. Love. Action. Hope. Smile. Inspiration. Energy. Affection. Transformation. Wonderful, marvelous, beautiful. Exchange. Recycling. Learning.”

Read up on all of the 2018 Sustainable Favela Network exchanges here.

*RioOnWatch is a project of the NGO Catalytic Communities