• English
  • Português
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
RioOnWatch
  • Home
    • Highlighted Stories
    • Understanding Rio
    • Reference Articles
  • Communities
    • Central
    • South Zone
    • North Zone
    • West Zone
    • Greater Rio
  • Policies
    • Public Security
    • Housing
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Health
    • Sanitation
  • Violations
    • Human Rights
    • Housing Rights
    • Police Violence
    • Government Neglect
  • Organizing
    • Community Organizing
    • Community Solution
    • Resistance
    • Sustainability
    • Participation
    • Protest
    • Culture
    • Responsible Tourism
  • Content Map
    • by Community Contributors
    • by Int’l Observers
    • Series
      • Anti-Racist Series
      • Energy Justice Series
    • Event Reports
    • Video Stories
    • Photo-Essays
    • Interviews/Profiles
    • Research & Analysis
    • Book Reviews
    • Film Reviews
    • Listicles
    • Opinion
    • Reference
    • Podcasts
    • Translated Articles
  • About
    • Timeline
    • Our Reporting Policy
    • License
    • Feedback
  • For Journos
  • Donate
Latest News
  • [ January 31, 2023 ] Anielle Franco: From Maré’s Alleyways to Minister of Racial Equality Democracy
  • [ January 27, 2023 ] ‘Let’s Walk Together’: Brazilian Minister of Racial Equality Anielle Franco’s Inauguration Speech in Full #MarielleLegacy
  • [ January 25, 2023 ] Rio’s Urban Peripheries Literary Festival Comes to Maré and Pays Homage to Marielle Franco, Lima Barreto and Pai Santana *Highlight
  • [ January 23, 2023 ] 1st Festival of Social Museology Held in Rio de Janeiro: Community Museums as Tools of Resistance by International Observers
  • [ January 16, 2023 ] 2022 Best and Worst International Reporting on Rio de Janeiro’s Favelas [EDITORIAL] #MediaWatch
Home#EvictionsWatchThe Story of a Family from Morro da Providência

The Story of a Family from Morro da Providência

By Roberto Marinho • Translation by Rachel Fox • December 4, 2012

Clique aqui para Português

This is the story of my family from Morro da Providência. Despite the city’s repeated interference, we have managed to stay in the same place since we arrived here. And so begins the story of Bernardino and Aurora….

They came to Rio de Janeiro in 1942, and settled on Morro da Providência, where Bernardino found land he could afford. Bernardino tells his grandchildren how they came from the Northeast by ship during World War II, taking the risk that their boat would be fired on by German submarines, which were attacking ships along the Brazilian coast. When they arrived, he was about 32 years old and already retired due to a streetcar accident in Alagoas. Aurora was 22. They built their home here, were married and had 12 children.

In a very small, simple stucco house, Bernardino begins his life story by describing the special difficulties of living in this place at that time. Imagine transporting everything you need to build a house up a long, steep staircase like the one in Providência. They would line up friends and family from one end of the stairs to the other so they could get all the construction materials – bricks, sand, rock, etc. – to the top without wearing anybody out. It has been more than 70 years of struggle and difficulty. Everything that exists today at number 241 Ladeira do Barroso is the result of the sweat, physical effort, and savings of my grandfather, his children and grandchildren. And we can’t forget all the friends and neighbors who are also a part of this story.

In this story, all 12 children and many of the grandchildren and great-grandchildren were born and raised here. Today 8 of our families live here: 4 of Bernardino and Aurora’s children, 7 grandchildren, 3 great-grandchildren – and their spouses. When we get together for birthdays, anniversaries, and the holidays at the end of the year, there are usually around 33 of us.

We are not against progress in Morro da Providência. But we want to be a part of this progress, to have a place to live that’s comparable to what we have now, in the same area, since our whole life revolves around this neighborhood: school, market, work, church, among other things. Not to mention the difficulties we have with our family members who are bedridden and need constant daily care.

We have tried several times to negotiate with the Municipal Secretary of Housing (SMH) at home and at the SMH building, but our negotiations have never left the realm of promises and verbal answers. What the city is offering does not meet our needs. The city’s proposals: temporary subsidized rent until new residential apartments are built; cash compensation for our homes; or assistance in purchasing an apartment far from our neighborhood, in places such as Santa Cruz, Senador Camará, and Bangu.

The offer of subsidized rent is not viable, since the amount the city would contribute is much less than the local cost of rent. Also, what the city is offering in compensation is not even enough to buy a kitchenette anywhere near Providência. And the assisted purchase program has already caused endless trouble for a Providência family that bought property from a third party who wasn’t the actual owner. The matter is still not resolved. Keep in mind how difficult it is to find something livable for the amount the city is offering.

For political and financial reasons, the city has already demolished several houses along the staircase, and it wants to demolish not only our family’s buildings, but also all these years of our family history. We are people who have fought for our rights like any other citizens of Rio. We want equal housing rights. Only those who live here truly understand the needs of the community. It doesn’t help to come up here, build a cable car, and think that everything is going to change and improve. The city keeps saying that the Porto Maravilha and Morar Carioca construction projects will bring the city together. The only “bringing together” we have observed is the bringing together of the city and the tourists – these projects don’t help to integrate the citizens of Rio who live in this community or others like it. That’s not what the city government is interested in.

All we want is a new building in exchange for the one we have now, with the same provisions and location. To trade one key for another. This is not our requirement alone, but that of all the residents involved in this struggle.

The demands of all of the residents of Morro da Providência, since the beginning of construction:

  • Suitable housing for all on Morro da Providência.
  • Information about the project from the city to all residents, with specific information for the eight affected areas.
  • Community participation in project planning. The community’s voice should be considered and its position incorporated in project decisions.
  • Any necessary relocation should be carried out nearby, and the relocation should only occur upon completion of construction, guaranteeing the keys will be turned over to the resident.
  • In case of relocation due to the area being classified as at-risk, we demand an independent technical appraisal. If this appraisal confirms the risk, the community agrees to move to another area nearby upon the completion of new residential units, with the guarantee that the keys will be turned over to the resident. If the appraisal does not confirm the risk, the area should be developed, with the guarantee that the community can stay there.

The city’s intervention in Providência should allow for the following, in this order: 1) residents to stay in their current locations; 2) relocation within the same area; 3) compensation, under special circumstances, only when chosen by the resident.

The family’s history, in photos:


The author maintains a Facebook profile, Ideais de Uma Luta Morro da Providência, to call attention to the facts and occurrences that insiders share about the public works taking place in Providência today.

  • Central Rio
  • CJI
  • collective action
  • historic preservation
  • history
  • Morar Carioca
  • mutirão
  • Porto Maravilha
  • Providência
  • resident account
Previous

Veta Dilma: Rio’s State-Sponsored Oil Royalties Protest

Next

Demolished Memory

  • ‘Let’s Walk Together’: Brazilian Minister of Racial Equality Anielle Franco’s Inauguration Speech in Full
    By Anielle Franco • Translation by Kay Alvito • January 27, 2023
  • 2022 Best and Worst International Reporting on Rio de Janeiro’s Favelas [EDITORIAL]
    By RioOnWatch Editorial • Translation by Staff • January 16, 2023
  • Permissiveness for the Self-Described ‘Patriots.’ Bullets for the Favelas. What #VoicesFromSocialMedia Say About the Brasília Attacks
    By Tatiana Lima • Translation by Staff • January 15, 2023

  • Understanding Energy Justice and Efficiency in Rio’s Favelas [VIDEO]
    By Jaqueline Suarez • Translation by Pilar Boyero • December 13, 2021
  • Pedra Branca and the Energy Dilemmas of Rio’s Urbanization: From Charcoal to Electricity
    By Antonio Alonso, Iamni Torres Jager • Translation by Trisha Ponti • November 1, 2021
  • Energy That Comes From Waste: Biodigester Turns Sewage into Biogas in Vale Encantado Favela [VIDEO]
    By Jaqueline Suarez • Translation by Saskia Wright • August 1, 2021

RioOnWatch’s anti-racist reporting series won silver in the 2022 inaugural The Anthem Awards, in the Diversity, Equity & Inclusion category among Best Local Awareness Programs.
A Project of

About

In May 2010, Catalytic Communities launched what was originally Rio Olympics Neighborhood Watch (hence RioOnWatch), a program to bring visibility to favela community voices in the lead-up to the 2016 Rio Olympics. This news site, RioOnWatch.org, grew into a much-needed and unique reference featuring favela perspectives on the urban transformation of Rio. With diverse and deeply interlinked articles by a mix of community reporters, resident opinions, solidarity reporters, international observers, and academic researchers, we work to engender a more accurate picture of favelas, their contributions to the city, and the potential of favela-led community development in Rio and around the world.

Contact & Support

contact@rioonwatch.org
WhatsApp +55.21.991.976.444
USA VOIP +1.301.637.7360

Volunteer | Donate

10 Years! Check Out Our Story:

Awards

Special Thanks

Fundação Heinrich Böll Brasil
World Habitat
Fideicomiso de la Tierra Caño Martín Peña
Pastoral de Favelas
Center for CLT Innovation
Global Land Alliance
Ecocity Builders
Mansueto Institute for Urban Innovation
SDSU Behner Stiefel Center
The Rio Times
Forum Grita Baixada
Beto Paixão Graphic Design
Architecture Museum of Vienna
Yale School of Architecture

  • Home
    • Highlighted Stories
    • Understanding Rio
    • Reference Articles
  • Communities
    • Central
    • South Zone
    • North Zone
    • West Zone
    • Greater Rio
  • Policies
    • Public Security
    • Housing
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Health
    • Sanitation
  • Violations
    • Human Rights
    • Housing Rights
    • Police Violence
    • Government Neglect
  • Organizing
    • Community Organizing
    • Community Solution
    • Resistance
    • Sustainability
    • Participation
    • Protest
    • Culture
    • Responsible Tourism
  • Content Map
    • by Community Contributors
    • by Int’l Observers
    • Series
      • Anti-Racist Series
      • Energy Justice Series
    • Event Reports
    • Video Stories
    • Photo-Essays
    • Interviews/Profiles
    • Research & Analysis
    • Book Reviews
    • Film Reviews
    • Listicles
    • Opinion
    • Reference
    • Podcasts
    • Translated Articles
  • About
    • Timeline
    • Our Reporting Policy
    • License
    • Feedback
  • For Journos
  • Donate

© 2023 Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike